Download Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan
Idea in picking the most effective book Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan to read this day can be gotten by reading this resource. You can discover the most effective book Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan that is offered in this world. Not only had the books published from this country, however likewise the various other nations. And currently, we mean you to check out Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan as one of the reading materials. This is only one of the best publications to collect in this website. Take a look at the page and also look the books Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan You can find lots of titles of guides provided.
Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan
Download Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan
Learn the method of doing something from numerous sources. Among them is this publication entitle Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan It is a very well known publication Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan that can be referral to review currently. This recommended publication is among the all excellent Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan collections that remain in this site. You will additionally discover various other title as well as themes from numerous authors to browse below.
Below, we have various e-book Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan and collections to check out. We also offer variant kinds as well as sort of the e-books to search. The enjoyable publication, fiction, history, unique, science, as well as various other kinds of books are available right here. As this Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan, it turneds into one of the preferred publication Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan collections that we have. This is why you remain in the best website to see the incredible e-books to have.
It will not take even more time to purchase this Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan It won't take more cash to print this publication Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan Nowadays, people have been so clever to utilize the innovation. Why don't you use your kitchen appliance or other device to conserve this downloaded and install soft data publication Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan This means will certainly let you to consistently be gone along with by this e-book Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan Obviously, it will be the most effective close friend if you read this book Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan till finished.
Be the very first to purchase this e-book now and obtain all reasons you should read this Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan Guide Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan is not just for your responsibilities or requirement in your life. E-books will certainly constantly be an excellent pal in every single time you review. Now, let the others understand about this page. You could take the perks and also share it additionally for your friends as well as people around you. By by doing this, you can truly get the significance of this publication Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee And Civil War History (Civil War America), By Alan T. Nolan profitably. What do you consider our suggestion below?
Of all the heroes produced by the Civil War, Robert E. Lee is the most revered and perhaps the most misunderstood. Lee is widely portrayed as an ardent antisecessionist who left the United States Army only because he would not draw his sword against his native Virginia, a Southern aristocrat who opposed slavery, and a brilliant military leader whose exploits sustained the Confederate cause.
Alan Nolan explodes these and other assumptions about Lee and the war through a rigorous reexamination of familiar and long-available historical sources, including Lee's personal and official correspondence and the large body of writings about Lee. Looking at this evidence in a critical way, Nolan concludes that there is little truth to the dogmas traditionally set forth about Lee and the war.
- Sales Rank: #1841082 in Books
- Brand: Brand: The University of North Carolina Press
- Published on: 1996-09-23
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.02" h x .55" w x 5.98" l, .86 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 243 pages
- Used Book in Good Condition
From Publishers Weekly
Lawyer and historian Nolan considers how the historical Lee differed from the legends about him.
Copyright 1996 Cahners Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
Marching in the tracks of such historians as Bruce Catton, Thomas Connelly, and T. Harry Williams, Nolan tries to unhorse the mythic Lee. In pointing out the contradictions between the legend and the man, Nolan shows that Lee the slaveholder was not antislavery, that the reluctant secessionist endorsed Southern independence, that the general lost the war by his repeated offensive thrusts and provincial vision--and more. Lawyer Nolan's brief challenges all the commonplaces by insisting that we look at the record rather than the legend in viewing the man, and through him, the war itself. Nolan's debunking is less original than he claims, and his own reading of Lee is somewhat idiosyncratic. But he makes a forceful case for rethinking Lee and all the myths his memory has draped over the Lost Cause. A provocative book, highly recommended for university and major public libraries.
- Randall Miller, St. Jo seph's Univ., Philadelphia
Copyright 1991 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Review
Nolan dethrones the myth of 'the Marble Man' with meticulous research.
"New Republic"
[Future authors] will have to face up to Nolan's material and we will all be the better for it.
"Washington Post"
"His argument is a persuasive one, artfully fashioned to stimulate the critical assessment he seeks.
"New York Times Book Review""
"Lee Considered" should be required reading for anyone who would understand the Confederacy's most famous soldier.
Gary W. Gallagher
"No student of the Civil War can afford to ignore the challenging and controversial conclusions of this study.
James M. McPherson, author of the Pulitzer Prize-winning "Battle Cry of Freedom: The Era of the Civil War""
ÝFuture authors¨ will have to face up to Nolan's material and we will all be the better for it.
"Washington Post"
His argument is a persuasive one, artfully fashioned to stimulate the critical assessment he seeks.
"New York Times Book Review"
No student of the Civil War can afford to ignore the challenging and controversial conclusions of this study.
James M. McPherson, author of the Pulitzer Prize-winning "Battle Cry of Freedom: The Era of the Civil War"
"Nolan doesn't question Lee's undeniable greatness. [He] subjects the sources to brutal cross examinations. . . . His purpose is to place Lee within his proper historical context. . . . Nolan asks the right questions about Lee, especially his generalship."
-- Peter S. Carmichael, "Civil War Times"
Most helpful customer reviews
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Turn to historian Robert K. Krick for questions relating to Lee and his Army
By William I. Brown
Nolan's book is worth reading if for no other reason than to seek the real truth elsewhere. Thought I might add to all of these very old posts about this book that the most esteemed modern day historian of Robert E. Lee's army is Robert K. Krick, former Chief of the National Park System for Fredericksburg-Chancellorsville-Spotsylvania. He wrote a lengthy review of this book many decades ago where he ripped it apart. I would suggest readers find it on the Internet (must be there), copy it, and place it in their copy of Nolan's book. When it comes to getting an honest opinion about all-things Lee and the Army of N. VA, I totally trust Bob Krick. He's done more research on Lee and his army than probably anyone. His son R.E.L. Krick is following in his father's footsteps. Bob Krick is also one of the few historians that has not fallen into the trap of believing the interpretation of James Longstreet as given in the novel The Killer Angels. Bob has written extensively on this subject and it's amazing how many historians think Longstreet was some darn genius of warfare when in fact his record proves otherwise; also terribly insubordinate time and again to Gen. Lee. Any man but the gentlemen Lee would have relieved him of command. If you ever get the chance to hear Bob Krick speak about Longstreet's performance at Gettysburg, definitely attend the presentation. And no, he does not use Longstreet as a scapegoat as Early did; he evidence of Longstreet's poor performance there, as well as Suffolk, Knoxville, and 2nd Manassas is quite something to hear.
26 of 33 people found the following review helpful.
A "Prosecution" of Robert E Lee, with mixed results...
By A Customer
As a Southerner whose ancestors fought for both the Confederacy AND the Union in the Civil War, I tend to disagree with both sides in the debate over "Lee Considered". I do agree with those who argue that a more balanced and realistic view of Robert E Lee is long overdue, and that Nolan's book does offer some telling blows at the Lee mythology. But, I also don't believe that Nolan has made the "convincing" case against Lee that some of the posters on this board would have you to believe. Nolan, who is a lawyer and not an historian (a fact that should always be kept in mind as you read this book), attempts to put the romantic, mythological Lee "on trial" and expose him for the flawed and decidedly unheroic person that Nolan believes him to be.
Like a good lawyer, Nolan denies trying to "convict" Lee in the beginning of the book, and even states that he admires him in some ways, but the rest of the book reveals Nolan to be committed to convicting his target of several specific charges. Namely: 1) That Lee was privately far more supportive of slavery than the Lee myth would have it; 2) That Lee was far more supportive of secession and "breaking up the Union" than his myth reveals; 3) That Lee made numerous mistakes as a General that helped cause the South's defeat - mistakes such as pursuing an aggressive, "go get'em" strategy that led to the highest casualty rates of any Civil War General and bled his smaller army dry; and 4) That Lee prolonged the Civil War longer than was necessary by continuing to fight after Gettysburg, which Nolan argues convinced Lee that the South was doomed to defeat, and therefore he should have urged the Confederacy to surrender, or at least refused to fight or encourage his men to make useless sacrifices for a cause he privately knew was doomed.
Nolan presents a good deal of evidence (much of it in Lee's own words), but like a good prosecutor he leaves out evidence which contradicts his theories, and he completely ignores the fact that Lee was a nineteenth-century man, not a late twentieth-century one. An historian would have put many of Lee's views into further context (without necessarily excusing them). Dr. James McPherson, the famed Civil War historian and author of "Battle Cry of Freedom", can hardly be called a "neo-Confederate" historian (if anything he's pro-Union), but even he has some problems with Nolan's book. A few years ago he wrote a criticism of "Lee Considered" in which he "judged" Nolan's "trial" of Lee, and while he found Lee to be "guilty" of being more pro-slavery than the Lee myth allows, he also found Lee to be "innocent" of prolonging the War (McPherson points out that the South still had a good chance of winning the war right up to Lincoln's reelection in November 1864), and that Nolan failed to "prove" many of his other charges, although McPherson argues that Nolan does raise some worthwhile questions about the accuracy of the traditional Lee myth. I fully agree with McPherson's views - this book is worth reading because it does offer a view of Lee that is in some ways more "realistic" than the Lee myth. However, Nolan fails to destroy Lee's reputation as a great general and one of the true "legends" of American military history. Overall, this book is quite a mixed bag, but it's still a thought-provoking, intellectually stimulating piece of work, even if Nolan is sometimes off-target.
11 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
A must read for any student of Lee.
By A Customer
Nolan's book isn't the Lee bashing book that I thought it would be thank goodness. My history instructor at college let me read this book when I told her I was a huge fan of General Lee's. Nolan states that he thinks Lee was a great man; moral, intelligent, and loved by his men. This is all true and any Lee basher will have to face up to these facts. Nolan simply tries to offer another side of Lee than many of the Lee "traditionalists" have not included, and that is the human side of Lee. Lee made errors like any man, and he was also the victim of the Southern way of thinking when Lee believed in a "gradual emancipation". Another important fact that was addressed by Nolan, which is the usual argument by Lee critics is his offensive strategy. Nolan points out that if Lee believed that the only way of truly winning a battle and ending the war was to fight "those people" on their own ground and drive them from it, which Lee did believe in, then he is not at fault. I don't believe this book is an attack on the ability or character of Lee, it is simply a well-rounded version of the "Lee tradition". My opinion of Lee has not changed since reading the book, I only feel he was human like the rest of us.
Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan PDF
Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan EPub
Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan Doc
Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan iBooks
Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan rtf
Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan Mobipocket
Lee Considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War History (Civil War America), by Alan T. Nolan Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar